Hi Warren,
Glad to see you again in the Forum.
My own practice regarding photos, is to include additional information on a separate piece if acid free paper. I like to use either Printfile or Light Impression brands 5"x7" photo pockets. Other sizes for smaller or larger prints. If I have a 5" X 7" print, I will place the notes in the photo pocket above the archival print. I do not write on the archival print. I much prefer to see the photographers notes without my own competing for space.
When Edaville removed much of the historic infrastructure and essentially a chance to get ones bearings, I began to note where the photographer may have been standing. Photos taken along the line may have had some recognizable landmark, now likely long gone.
In 2022, I visited Edaville with another former Edaville employee and engineer. We could find no trace of many one time "fixtures" including some of the original main line trackage that once led out from the water tower and beyond the coal pocket. While these changes do not affect our memories and abilities to recognize old photo locations, that may not be the case for younger enthusiasts. Our old photos may have no meaning to the next owners of our collections.
While I was interested in learning how others felt about this subject, I had already made up my own mind to provide as much detail as possible. I'm grateful for the interest.
Now, on another subject, namely vintage two foot tickets, let me ask the following of you. Are you aware that in the 1930's, when railfans began to visit the Sandy River and the Bridgton roads, that certain tickets were stamped and dated to simulate earlier cancellation and use? This is evident with many cardstock passenger tickets, backstamped with dates from 1930 to 1935 on the Sandy River lines and later dates on the Bridgton road.
One photographer and well known collector had acquired ticket punches and rubber stamps that he then put to work on vintage un-circulated tickets. Essentially, he "made up" authentic looking used tickets. In 2025, my suspicions of this were verified when in a collection I purchased, there was a scrap.piece of paper bearing numerous stamp strikes from assorted dater cancellation stamps. Is there any harm to this? I would say no, although if you are a ticket collector and you lay in your tickets by serial number, your cancellation dates may get a little out of whack.
When I found this out, I remembered the absolute character that Lawrence "Brownie" Brown was, and had a good laugh at thinking of him making up his vintage tickets for sale to other collectors. Lawrence was a "scrounger" of the finest order and picked up everything and anything two foot. We are all lucky to have had him as one of the early fans and photographers. His photos are prized to me.
There are many unanswered questions still to be heard in our hobby, it's a lot of fun to try and figure out the answers. Thanks for reading and please comment with your own experiences.